Methods and apparatus for detecting a composition of an audience of an information presenting device

ABSTRACT

Methods and apparatus for detecting a composition of an audience of an information presenting device are disclosed. A disclosed example method includes: capturing at least one image of the audience; determining a number of people within the at least one image; prompting the audience to identify its members if a change in the number of people is detected based on the number of people determined to be within the at least one image; and if a number of members identified by the audience is different from the determined number of people after a predetermined number of prompts of the audience, adjusting a value to avoid excessive prompting of the audience.

RELATED APPLICATIONS

This patent arises from a continuation of U.S. application Ser. No.10/538,692, now U.S. Patent ______, which was filed on Jun. 10, 2005 andis a U.S. national stage of International Patent Application Serial No.PCT/US02/39625, filed Dec. 11, 2002 under 35 U.S.C. § 371. Both U.S.application Ser. No. 10/538,692 and International Patent ApplicationSerial No. PCT/US02/39625 are hereby incorporated by reference in theirentirety.

FIELD OF THE DISCLOSURE

This disclosure relates generally to audience demographics measurementand, more particularly, to methods and apparatus for detecting acomposition of an audience of an information presenting device.

BACKGROUND

Audience measurement of broadcasted television and/or radio programs hasbeen practiced for many years. Audience measurement devices typicallycollect two kinds of information from households, namely, tuninginformation (e.g., information indicating the content presented to theaudience such as channel information, time of consumption information,program information, etc.) and people information (e.g., informationabout the demographics of the audience). These two types of informationare combined to produce meaningful ratings data.

People information has historically been gathered by people meters.People meters have been constructed in many different manners. Forexample, some people meters are active devices which seek to determinethe composition of the audience by, for instance, analyzing visualimages of the audience to actively determine the identity of the peoplein the audience. Such active determination involves comparing facialfeatures of an individual appearing in a captured image to one or morepreviously stored facial feature images to search for a match. Otherpeople meters are passive devices which prompt the members of theviewing audience to identify themselves by logging themselves in atspecific times. These specific prompting times can be independent of thetuning information and at fixed time intervals (i.e., time-basedprompting) or they can be tied to the tuning information and beperformed, for example, when the channel changes (i.e., channelchange-based prompting).

The time-based prompting technique poses a danger of under sampling orover sampling the data. For example, if the prompts are spaced too farapart in time, audience members may enter or leave the room betweenprompts. If the audience does not notify the people meter of suchentrances/exits, audience composition data and audience change timing islost. Alternatively, if the time prompts are spaced too closely in time,the audience members may become annoyed and/or reduce their compliancewith the prompt requests. Again, audience composition data is lost insuch circumstances.

The channel change-based prompting technique discussed above poses thedanger of over sampling the data. As explained above, such overlyfrequent prompting may cause irritation and/or result in a decrease incompliance and a corresponding loss of data collection and/or invaliddata.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 is a schematic illustration of an example apparatus constructedin accordance with the teachings of the invention.

FIG. 2 is a more detailed schematic illustration of the exampleapparatus of FIG. 1.

FIG. 3 is a schematic illustration of an example implementation of theapparatus of FIGS. 1-2.

FIGS. 4A-4D are a flow chart illustrating example machine readableinstructions which may be executed by the apparatus of FIG. 3 toimplement the apparatus of FIGS. 1-2.

FIG. 5 is a schematic illustration of an example people counterconstructed in accordance with the teachings of the invention.

FIG. 6 is a schematic illustration of an example blob discriminator.

FIGS. 7A-7C are a flow chart illustrating example machine readableinstructions which may be executed by the apparatus of FIG. 3 toimplement the apparatus of FIGS. 5 and 6.

FIGS. 8A-8G illustrate example histograms developed by the apparatus ofFIGS. 5 and 6.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

FIG. 1 is a schematic illustration of an example apparatus 10 fordetecting a composition of an audience of an information presentingdevice (not shown). The information presenting device may be, forexample, a television and the audience may be, for example, astatistically sampled household selected to develop television ratingsdata. Alternatively, the information presenting device may be a personalvideo recorder, a computer monitor, a radio with or without a visualdisplay, or any other communication device designed to presentinformation for consumption by one or more individuals. Similarly, theaudience can be made up of any group of one or more individuals. Forexample, the group need not be selected via statistical sampling or anyother technique. In the following, it is further assumed thatdemographic information (e.g., age, sex, ethnic background, incomelevel, education level, etc.) concerning each of the expected audiencemembers has been collected and stored in association with uniqueexpected audience member names or pseudo names in a conventionalfashion. As a result, when the apparatus 10 obtains the name(s) orpseudo name(s) of the audience member(s), it has also effectivelyobtained the demographic composition of the audience.

As shown in FIG. 1, the apparatus 10 includes an audience changedetector 12 and a content collector 14. The audience change detector 12captures one or more images of the audience; determines a number ofpeople within the image(s); and prompts the audience to identify itsmembers if a change in the number of people in the audience is visuallydetected. The content collector 14 monitors source data to identify aprogram being consumed (e.g., viewed, listened to, etc.) by theaudience. Persons of ordinary skill in the art will readily appreciatethat any known technique can be utilized to identify the program beingconsumed. For example, the content collector 14 may identify aconsumption time and a source of the program being consumed by theaudience. The consumption time and the source identification data may beutilized to identify the program by, for example, cross-referencing aprogram guide configured, for example, as a look up table. The sourceidentification data may, for example, be the identity of a tuned channel(e.g., channel 3) obtained, for example, by monitoring the tuner of theinformation presenting device. The source data and the consumption timemay be recorded for later use in identifying the program either locallyor remotely following exportation of the data, and/or the source dataand the consumption time may be utilized immediately for on-the-flyprogram identification.

Alternatively or additionally, in the visual presentation context (e.g.,television viewing), codes embedded in the vertical blanking interval ofthe program being viewed may be utilized by the content collector 14 topositively identify the program being consumed by the audience.

A detailed illustration of an example implementation of the apparatus 10is shown in FIG. 2. As shown in FIG. 2, the audience change detector 12of FIG. 2 includes an image sensor 18 to capture images of the audienceconsuming the program(s) presented on the information presentationdevice. Images are preferably only captured when the informationpresenting device is in an “on” state. The image sensor 18 may beimplemented in any known way. For example, it may be implemented by aninfrared imager, or a digital camera such as a charge-coupled device CCDcamera.

For the purpose of determining a number of people appearing in theimages captured by the image sensor 18, the audience change detector 12of the apparatus 10 is further provided with a people counter 20. Thepeople counter 20 may determine the number of people within the image(s)in many different ways. However, a preferred method identifies peoplewithin the image(s) by detecting changes indicative of movement betweensuccessive images. An example people counter 20 and an example manner ofimplementing the same are discussed below in connection with FIGS. 5-8.

In order to determine if the number of audience members has changed, theaudience change detector 12 is further provided with a change detector22. The change detector 22 compares the number of people counted in theimage(s) by the people counter 20 to a value representative of aprevious number of people in the audience. The value representative ofthe previous audience count may, for example, be the audience count thepeople counter 20 developed in analyzing the last image or set ofimages, or, in, for example, the case of the first audience imageanalysis (e.g., the first image(s) collected after a power-up event), itmay be a default value (e.g., 0). If a difference exists between theaudience count developed by the people counter 20 and the previousnumber of people in the audience, the change detector 22 develops anoutput signal indicating an audience composition change has beendetected.

As shown in FIG. 2, the audience change detector 12 includes a prompter24 which is responsive to the output signal developed by the changedetector 22 to request the audience to identify its members. If thechange detector 22 identifies a difference between the number of peoplein the image(s) and the value representative of the previous number ofpeople in the audience, the prompter 24 outputs a signal to the audienceprompting the audience to identify the individual(s) in the room and/orto identify any individual(s) that have entered or left the room. Thesignal can be any type of human perceptible signal. For example, theprompter 24 may be implemented by a visual display and the signal outputby the prompter 24 may be a viewable request. For instance, the visualdisplay may be the television screen or a separate, dedicated displaydevice and the visual signal may be a menu requesting the audience toidentify the current audience member(s) (or alternatively any newlydeparted and/or newly added audience member(s)) from a list ofpredetermined possible members. Alternatively, the prompter 24 may be aflashing light or an audible sound providing a sensible signal to theaudience that an audience count change has been detected.

Regardless of the type of signal employed (e.g., visual, audible, etc.),in the illustrated example the people counter 20, the change detector 22and the prompter 24 cooperate to prompt the audience member(s) to logthemselves(s) in whenever a change in the number of audience membersoccurs. As a result, the audience is neither oversampled (i.e., promptedexcessively), nor undersampled (i.e., prompted too infrequently suchthat audience change times are missed). Also, in the event all audiencemembers leave the room, the apparatus 10 automatically detects andrecords that there is no audience members, thereby collecting accurateaudience measurement data even when no audience member is present torespond to a prompt.

In order to receive data from the audience member(s), the audiencechange detector 12 is further provided with an input device 26 such as aconventional IR transmit-receive pair, a mouse, a keyboard, atouchscreen, a touchpad, a microphone and voice recognition engine,and/or any other means of inputting data into a computing device. In theexample shown in the figures, the input device 26 is an IR receiver andthe audience is provided with one or more conventional IR transmittersfor remotely entering data into the apparatus 10.

As also shown in FIG. 2, the audience change detector 12 includes a timestamper 28 and a memory 30. The time stamper 28 includes a conventionalclock and calendar, and functions to associate a time and date withrecorded events. For example, if the change detector 22 detects a changein the audience count, it outputs the counted number of audience membersto the time stamper 28 and/or the memory 30. The time stamper 28 thenassociates a time and date with the new audience count by, for example,appending the time/date data to the end of the audience count. Thecomplete data package (i.e., audience count, time and date) is stored inthe memory 30. Similarly, whenever data such as, for example, theidentity of an audience member is entered via the input device 26, thetime stamper 28 associates a time and date with the data. The memory 30stores the entered data, time and date for later analysis.

For the purpose of determining if one or more members of the audience isnot being identified in response to a prompt from the prompter 24, theaudience change detector 12 is further provided with a compliancedetector 32. As shown in FIG. 2, the compliance detector 32 monitors theinputs from the audience and compares them to the audience countdeveloped by the people counter 20. If a number of members identified bythe audience via the input device 26 is different from the determinednumber of people after a predetermined number of prompts of theaudience, the change detector 22 causes the difference between thenumber of members identified by the audience and the number of peopledetermined from the image(s) by the people counter 20 to be recorded inthe memory 30 as a number of unidentified audience members. The timestamper 28 ensures the records indicative of the presence of theunidentified audience member(s) is time stamped and dated, as explainedabove.

In the event such unidentified audience member(s) are detected, thecompliance detector 32 adjusts a value representative of the previousnumber of people in the audience by a difference between the number ofmembers identified by the audience and the number of people determinedfrom the image(s) by the people counter 20 to avoid excessive promptingof the audience. In other words, the value indicative of the lastaudience count made by the people counter 20 is adjusted so that,assuming the audience composition does not change in the interim, at thenext image collection and evaluation by the people counter 20, thechange detector 22 will compare the audience count developed by thepeople counter 20 to an audience count which includes the unidentifiedaudience member(s). Therefore, since in this example, no change in thenumber of audience members has occurred, the change detector 22 will notdetect a change and the prompter 24 will not prompt the audience eventhough the unidentified audience member(s) are present. As a result, thecompliance detector 32 functions to avoid excessively prompting theaudience if an audience member is refusing to identify himself/herself.

In the example of FIG. 2, the content collector 14 includes a programdetector 34 and an output device 36. The program detector 34 monitorssource data to determine the source of the program being consumed by theaudience. For example, the program detector 34 may monitor the tuner ofthe information presenting device (e.g., a television) to determinewhich channel is currently tuned (e.g., a television program on channel3 is being viewed). Alternatively or additionally, the program detector34 may monitor a video screen of the information presenting device todetermine if a visual source identification signal is present during oneor more vertical blanking intervals of the program being consumed.Alternatively or additionally, the program detector 34 may monitor anaudio output of the information presenting device to determine if anaudio source identification signal is present in the program beingconsumed. Irrespective of how the data is gathered, the detected sourceinformation is time stamped by the time stamper 28 and stored in thememory 30 for subsequent analysis.

In the example of FIG. 2, the output device 36 periodically exports therecorded data from the memory 30 to a remote data analysis computer (notshown) via a network such as the Internet or the like. The data analysiscomputer identifies audiences (e.g., the individual(s) comprising anaudience and, thus, the demographic composition of the audience) and theprograms, or parts of programs, those audiences consumed. This analysiscan be performed, for example, by cross-referencing the recorded time,date and source data for the subject audiences to a program guide.Alternatively, the data analysis could be performed locally and exportedvia a network or the like to a data collection computer for furtherprocessing. In either event, the data collection computer typicallyassembles data from multiple different households to develop ratingsdata. No images are transmitted or extracted from the apparatus 10 undereither the local analysis or remote analysis model. The exportation ofdata can be done through a wired or wireless connection.

An example apparatus 60 for implementing the apparatus 10 of FIGS. 1-2is shown in FIG. 3. The apparatus 10 of FIG. 3 includes an image sensor18 such as an analog camera and a digitizer 52 for digitizing the analogimage(s) captured by the image sensor 18 into digital data. The imagesensor 18 and digitizer 52 may alternatively be implemented by a singledevice such as a digital camera.

The apparatus 50 of the instant example includes a processor 54. Forexample, the processor 54 may be implemented by one or more Intel®microprocessors from the Pentium® family, the Itanium™ family or theXScale™ family. Of course, other processors from other families are alsoappropriate.

As is conventional, the processor 54 is in communication with a mainmemory 30 via a bus. The memory 30 stores the data developed by theapparatus 10. It also stores computer readable instructions which, whenexecuted, cause the processor 54 to determine a number of people withinthe image(s) captured by the sensor 18, and to develop a prompt signalrequesting the audience to identify its member(s) if a change in thenumber of people in the audience is visually detected

The memory 30 may include a volatile memory and a non-volatile memory.The volatile memory may be implemented by Synchronous Dynamic RandomAccess Memory (SDRAM), Dynamic Random Access Memory (DRAM), RAMBUSDynamic Random Access Memory (RDRAM) and/or any other type of randomaccess memory device. The non-volatile memory may be implemented byflash memory and/or any other desired type of memory device. Access tothe main memory 30 may be controlled by a memory controller (not shown)in a conventional manner.

The memory 30 may also include one or more mass storage devices forstoring software and data. Examples of such mass storage devices includefloppy disk drives, hard drive disks, compact disk drives and digitalversatile disk (DVD) drives.

The apparatus 50 also includes a communication block or interfacecircuit 56. The interface circuit 56 may be implemented by any type ofwell known interface standard, such as an Ethernet interface, auniversal serial bus (USB), and/or a third generation input/output(3GIO) interface.

One or more input devices 56 are included in or connected to theinterface circuit 56. The input device(s) permit a user to enter dataand commands into the processor 54. The input device(s) can beimplemented by, for example, an IR transmit/receive pair, a keyboard, amouse, a touchscreen, a track-pad, a trackball, isopoint and/or a voicerecognition system.

An output device 24 is also connected to the interface circuit 56. Theoutput device 24 is responsive to the prompt signal output by theprocessor 54 to output an indication requesting the audience to identifyits members. In the example of FIG. 3, the output device 24 is a liquidcrystal display (LCD) which outputs a visually perceptible promptsignal. However, the output device 24 may additionally or alternativelybe implemented by, for example, other visual and/or audible displaydevices (e.g., a cathode ray tube (CRT) display, a printer and/orspeakers).

The interface circuit 56 also includes a communication device such as amodem or network interface card to facilitate exchange of data withexternal computers via a network (e.g., an Ethernet connection, adigital subscriber line (DSL), a telephone line, coaxial cable, acellular telephone system, etc.). It may also include a communicationdevice such as an infrared decoder to receive and decode IR signalstransmitted to the apparatus 60 by one or more audience members

An example software program for implementing the apparatus of FIGS. 1-2,is shown in FIGS. 4A-4D. In this example, the program is for executionby a processor such as the processor 54 shown in the example of FIG. 3,and the program is embodied in software stored on a tangible medium suchas a compact disk (CD), a floppy disk, a hard drive, a digital versatiledisk (DVD), or a memory associated with the processor 54. However,persons of ordinary skill in the art will readily appreciate that theentire program or parts thereof could alternatively be executed by adevice other than the processor 54 and/or embodied in firmware ordedicated hardware in a well known manner. For example, any or all ofthe people counter 20, the change detector 22, the time stamper 28, theprogram detector 34, and/or the compliance detector 32 could beimplemented by software, hardware, and/or firmware. Further, althoughthe example program is described with reference to the flowchartillustrated in FIGS. 4A-4D, persons of ordinary skill in the art willreadily appreciate that many other methods of implementing the exampleapparatus 10 may alternatively be used. For example, the order ofexecution of the blocks may be changed, and/or some of the blocksdescribed may be changed, eliminated, and/or combined.

In the example of FIG. 4A, the program starts at power up when theprocessor 54 engages in various conventional housekeeping tasks such asinitializing the memory, etc. (block 100). The people counter 20 thenresets the variables LAST COUNT and CURRENT COUNT to zero (block 102).The processor 54 then determined whether the information presentingdevice (in this example, a viewing device such as a television) is in anon state (block 104). If the information presenting device is in an offstate, the processor 54 enters a wait loop until the informationpresenting device is turned on. No audience images are collected unlessthe information presenting device is in an “on” state.

Assuming the information presenting device is in an on state, the peopleprompter 24 is driven to prompt the audience to identify its member(s)(block 106). The apparatus 60 then awaits an input from the audience(block 108). When an audience input is received via, for example, theinput device 26 (block 108), the processor 54 updates the database withthe input data (e.g., an audience member's identity) (block 110). Thetime stamper 28 may record a time and date in association with the inputdata. The people counter 20 then increments the LAST COUNT variable toreflect the presence of the audience member that identifiedhimself/herself (block 112).

The processor 54 then determines if a predetermined length of time(e.g., 10 seconds) has elapsed since the last input was received fromthe audience (block 114). If the predetermined time has not elapsed(block 114), control returns to block 108 where the processor 54determines if another audience input has been received. If not, controlagain proceeds to block 114. Otherwise control advances to block 110where the database stored in the memory 30 is updated to reflect the newaudience data input. Control continues to loop through blocks 108-114until no audience inputs are received for the predetermined length oftime (block 114), at which point it is assumed that all audience membershave identified themselves (although this assumption is tested at block146 as explained below).

Assuming the predetermined length of time has elapsed without anyfurther audience inputs (block 114), control proceeds to block 116. Atblock 116, the program detector 34 identifies the source of the programbeing presented on the information presenting device. If a change in thesource has occurred (e.g., tuning changed from channel 3 to channel 11),or if a power on event just occurred (e.g., tuning changed from no tunedchannel to channel 12) (block 118), the database stored in the memory 30is updated with the new source information (block 120). As explainedabove, the time stamper 28 associates a time and date with the newsource information. If no source change or turn on event has occurred(block 118), control skips block 120 and proceeds directly to block 122.

At block 122, the image sensor 18 is activated to capture image(s) ofthe audience. The captured image(s) are digitized (block 124) and passedto the people counter 20. The people counter 20 then analyzes theimage(s) to determine if any person is located in the image(s) asexplained below in connection with FIGS. 5-8 (block 126). The variableCURRENT COUNT is set to reflect the number of persons in the image(s)(block 128). Control then advances to block 134.

At block 134, the change detector 22 determines if the CURRENT COUNTvalue (i.e., the number of persons counted in the captured image(s)) isequal to the LAST COUNT value (i.e., the number of persons countedimmediately prior to the capturing of the image(s) being analyzed). Ifthe CURRENT COUNT value and the LAST COUNT value are equal (block 134),control returns to block 116 because no audience change has occurred.Otherwise, control proceeds to block 136. Control continues to loopthrough blocks 116 -134 until an audience count change is detected(block 134).

Assuming an audience count change has been detected (block 134), thetime stamper 28 updates the database in the memory 30 with an entryindicating the time and date that an audience change occurred (block136). It then drives the prompter 24 to prompt the audience member(s) toidentify themselves(s) (block 138, FIG. 4C). If an audience input isreceived (block 140), the new data is written to the memory 30 (block142). If no audience input is received for a predetermined length oftime (e.g., 10 seconds) (block 144), control advances to block 146.Otherwise control continues to loop through blocks 140-144 as long asthe audience continues to input data.

Assuming that the audience has stopped inputting data (block 144), thecompliance detector 32 determines if the number of audience membersidentified by the inputs received from the audience is equal to theCURRENT COUNT developed from the captured image(s) by the people counter20 (block 146). If the audience identified less audience members thanthe people counter 20, then the compliance detector 32 determineswhether this discrepancy has occurred a predetermined number of timessequentially (e.g., three times in a row) (block 148). If not, controlproceeds to block 150. Otherwise, control advances to block 156 of FIG.4D.

Assuming for the moment that the number of audience members identifiedin the inputs received from the audience is equal to the number ofindividuals counted by the people counter 20, the compliance detector 32sets the LAST COUNT variable equal to the CURRENT COUNT value (block150). Setting the LAST COUNT variable in this manner ensures that onlychanges in the audience count result in audience prompts (see block134). After the LAST COUNT variable is set (block 150), the CURRENTCOUNT variable and the NONCOMPLIANT PERSON COUNT variable are bothre-set to zero (block 152).

The program detector 34 then verifies that the information presentingdevice is still in an on state (block 154). If so, control returns toblock 116 (FIG. 4B). Control continues to loop through blocks 116-154until the information presenting device is turned off (block 154), ornoncompliant persons are detected a predetermined number of timessequentially (block 148). If the information presenting device is turnedoff (block 154), control returns to block 102 (FIG. 4A).

Assuming that at least one audience member refuses to identifyhimself/herself for the predetermined number of times sequentially(block 148), control advances to block 156 (FIG. 4D). At block 156, thecompliance detector 32 calculates the number of unidentified individualsin the audience. In particular, the noncompliance detector 32 sets theNONCOMPLIANT PERSON COUNT variable equal to the value in the CURRENTCOUNT variable minus the number of audience members identified by theaudience inputs. The NONCOMPLIANT PERSON COUNT is then written to thememory 30 in association with a time and date stamp, thereby recordingthe number of unidentified persons in the audience (block 158). Thevariable LAST COUNT is then incremented by the value in the NONCOMPLIANTPERSON COUNT variable (block 160). Adjusting the LAST COUNT variable inthis manner avoids repeatedly prompting the audience to identifynoncompliant persons.

After re-setting the CURRENT COUNT variable to zero (block 162), theprogram detector 34 then verifies that the information presenting deviceis still in an on state (block 164). If so, control returns to block 116(FIG. 4B). If, on the other hand, the information presenting device isturned off (block 164), control returns to block 102 (FIG. 4A).

An example people counter 20 is schematically illustrated in FIG. 5. Thepeople counter 20 shown in FIG. 5 includes a motion detector 180. Themotion detector 180 receives a sequence of images from the image sensor18. In the example of FIG. 5, the image sensor 18 captures and providesimages to the motion detector 180 at a rate of 15 frames per second,although other rates of capture would likewise be appropriate.

The sequence of images may be digitized when the motion detector 180receives them, or, alternatively, the motion detector 180 may include adigitizer 52 to convert the images received from the image sensor 18into digital images. In the example of FIG. 5, the images are digitizedsuch that each pixel in each image is assigned an 8 bit binary value(i.e., a value of 0-255) which is representative of the correspondingimage data. Thus, each image can be thought of as an array of digitaldata with each element contained in the array corresponding to an 8 bitbinary value. The number of pixels assigned to each image (i.e., theresolution) can be selected at any desired level. However, the samearray size is preferably employed for each image. Additionally, JPEG (orother picture format) copies of the original images may be saved forfuture reference, if desired.

The motion detector 180 operates on each sequential pair of imagesreceived from the image sensor 18 to detect motion occurring between thetwo images. More specifically, assuming a given room containing anaudience is repeatedly photographed to create a series of images asexplained above, then if there is no movement for a given time period,there will be no significant difference between two successive images ofthe room taken during the period of no movement. Thus, the binary valuesof the elements in the image array for a first image will be identical(or substantially identical if noise errors or the like are present) tothe binary values of the corresponding elements in the image array for asecond image taken immediately after the first image. If, however, thereis movement between the time at which the first image is taken and thetime at which the second image is taken, the binary values of theelements in the image array for the second image will be different fromthe binary values of the corresponding elements in the image array forthe second image.

The motion detector 180 takes advantage of this fact to detectdifferences due to, for example, motion of audience members betweensuccessive images received from the image sensor 18 by comparing eachsuccessive pair of images on an element by element basis. In particular,the motion detector 180 develops a difference image corresponding toeach pair of successively received images by subtracting thecorresponding elements of one image array from the other image array. Inan extremely simplified example wherein each digitized image is an arrayof four elements, assuming that the elements of a first received imagehave the following values (90, 103, 23, and 203), and the correspondingelements of a second received image have the following values (90, 103,60 and 250), then the difference image computed by the motion detectoris an array of four elements having the following values (0, 0, −37,−47). In this example, there has been motion between the first andsecond image and, thus, some of the values in the difference image arenon-zero. The non-zero values represent points of motion. If there is nodifference between successive images, all the values in the differenceimage corresponding to those two successive images will be zero (orsubstantially zero as some small differences may appear due to noise orother error).

From the foregoing, persons of ordinary skill in the art will appreciatethat each difference image is typically a collection of motion pointslocalized around center(s) of motion. In order to correlate these motionpoints to objects in the images, the people counter 20 is furtherprovided with a shape outliner 182. The shape outliner 182 employs aprocess such as the well known convex hull algorithm to draw shapes orblobs encompassing the motion points. As is well known by persons ofordinary skill in the art, the convex hull algorithm joins all points ina set of points that satisfy a predetermined constraint into a blob orshape. The predetermined constraint may be a requirement that all of thepoints in the blob or shape are separated by less than a predetermineddistance. Since in this example, we are attempting to identify humans,the predetermined distance should be a distance corresponding to thesize of a human being. This distance may be a settable or programmableparameter and may be set based on the sizes of the expected audiencemembers at a given household.

Since there may not be enough data points in a difference image for theshape outliner 182 to draw meaningful shapes, the people counter 180 isfurther provided with an image amalgamator 184. For each image for whichthe people counter 20 is requested to develop a people count, the imageamalgamator 184 integrates or otherwise smoothes or filters thedifference images from a time interval in which the image to be analyzedis located into a single amalgamated image. For example, if the image tobe analyzed occurs at time i, the image amalgamator 184 will combine thedifference images from a time interval beginning at time i−k and endingat time i+c into a single image array, where k and c are preferablyequal, but may be different. The difference images may be combined intoan amalgamated image by summing the array corresponding to thedifference images on an element by element basis and then dividing eachsummed element by the number of elements summed (i.e., the number ofdifference images). Thus, like the arrays corresponding to thedifference images, the amalgamated image is an array of 8 bit binaryvalues (i.e., values ranging from 0 to 255).

As shown in FIG. 5, rather than acting directly on the differenceimages, the shape outliner 182 operates on the amalgamated imagecorresponding to an image being analyzed to draw blob(s) within theamalgamated image via the process explained above. Operating on theamalgamated images rather than directly on the difference imagesintegrates or averages error over a fixed time interval, which has atendency to reduce the size of noise objects that could be interpretedas motion relative to objects that are representative of actual motion.

From the foregoing, persons of ordinary skill in the art will appreciatethat the motion detector 180, the image amalgamator 184 and the shapeoutliner 182 function to reduce the problem of counting people appearingin an image to counting blob(s) reflecting center(s) of motion within animage.

For the purpose of discriminating human blob(s) appearing within theamalgamated image from non-human blob(s) (e.g., pets, random noise,inanimate objects, etc.), the people counter 20 may optionally befurther provided with a non-human filter 188. In the illustratedexample, the non-human filter 188 analyzes the shape(s) drawn within theamalgamated image by the shape outliner 182 to determine if any can beeliminated from the amalgamated image as not possibly corresponding to ahuman being. The non-human filter 188 may employ any logical test toeliminate blob(s) from the amalgamated image. For example, the non-humanfilter 188 may test the location(s) of the blob(s) to determine if theirlocation(s) identify them as not human. For instance, a blob located onthe ceiling of a room can be eliminated as not human. In addition tolocation based tests, the non-human filter 188 may also test the size ofthe shape. For example, if the size of a blob is beneath a certainthreshold or above a certain threshold, it may be eliminated as notreflecting a human sized object. The tests performed by the non-humanfilter 188 may be adjusted to suit the household being analyzed. Forexample, in a household with children, the non-human filter 188 mayemploy a lower size threshold than a household with no children.Similarly, in a household with no children, the non-human filter 188 mayidentify blob(s) appearing on the floor as non-human, whereas is may notbe allowed to identify blob(s) on the floor as non-human based purely ona floor location if the household includes children. If the test(s)employed by the non-human filter 188 are to be tailored to thedemographics of the household being analyzed, the test(s) should beadjusted at set up of the apparatus 20.

The non-human filter 188 may eliminate a blob from the amalgamated imagein many different ways. For example, the binary values in theamalgamated image giving rise to the object being eliminated can bezeroed, and the revised amalgamated image fed back to the shape outliner182 to create a new set of blob(s) in the amalgamated image excludingthe blob(s) eliminated by the non-human filter 188.

For the purpose of determining if any of the blob(s) appearing in theamalgamated image (optionally, as filtered by the non-human filter 188)represents a person, the people counter 20 is further provided with ablob discriminator 190. Were one to simply count the number of blobsappearing in the amalgamated image (optionally as filtered by thenon-human filter 188), false people counts might result in certaininstances. For example, if two people are located in an audience, butonly one of those people moves during a time period being analyzed, onlyone blob will appear in the amalgamated image, and simply counting blobswithout further refinement would result in an undercount. By way ofanother example, if two audience members move in a symmetrical fashionfor a given period of time, they could potentially appear as a singleblob in the amalgamated image. Simply counting blobs in this scenariowill again result in an undercount. The blob discriminator 190 solvesthis potential problem by ensuring only blob(s) that exhibit persistentmotion over a time period of interest are counted as persons.

To perform the persistent motion test, the blob discriminator 190 doesnot develop a count of the blobs appearing in every amalgamated image.Instead, a number of sequential amalgamated images are analyzed over aperiod of time. In particular, for each amalgamated image, the blob(s)contained therein are represented by symbols in a histogram. Although ablob can appear only once in any given amalgamated image, if the blobexhibits persistent motion, it will appear in multiple differentamalgamated images. For every time a blob appears in an amalgamatedimage and meets the convex hull criteria, a symbol is added to thehistogram. Therefore, the histogram tracks the number of times each blobexhibits motion over a period of time. After that period of time, thehistogram is analyzed and only those blobs that have exhibitedsufficient persistence of motion as indicated by the number of times asymbol corresponding to that blob appears in the histogram, areidentified as persons.

An example blob discriminator 190 is shown in FIG. 6. For the purpose ofidentifying the center of gravity of the blob(s) appearing in theamalgamated image, the blob discriminator 190 is provided with a centerlocator 192. In the illustrated example, the center locator 192 computesthe center of gravity of each blob in the amalgamated image by assigninga value to a plurality of points in the blob. The value assigned to agiven point corresponds to the X-axis location of the given point in theamalgamated image. The X-axis may, for example, correspond to the fieldof view of the image sensor. Once these point values are assigned, thecenter locator 192 averages the values. The average X-axis valuecomputed by the center locator 192 corresponds to the X-axis position ofthe center of gravity of the blob in question. The computed center ofgravity is then added to the histogram which is used to test thepersistence of the motion of each identified blob as explained above.

In order to add a symbol which is representative of the center ofgravity of the blob to the histogram, the blob discriminator 190 isfurther provided with a center comparator 194. The center comparator 194serves a gravitation function. In particular, whenever the centerlocator 192 computes a center of gravity of a blob, the centercomparator 194 compares the newly computed center of gravity to theexisting centers of gravity already appearing in the histogram. If thenewly computed center of gravity is the same as, or falls within apredetermined distance of, a center of gravity already represented inthe histogram, it is assumed that the newly computed center representsthe same object as the existing center. As a result, a symbolrepresentative of the newly computed center is added to the symbolrepresenting the existing center in the histogram. Preferably, everysymbol added to the histogram has the same size. Therefore, when asymbol is added to one or more existing symbols in the histogram, theexisting symbol “grows” in size.

Persons of ordinary skill in the art will readily appreciate that ahistogram such as that described above may be implemented in manydifferent ways. For example, it may be implemented graphically whereinsymbol(s) of the same size are placed at the X-axis location of theircorresponding blob(s). If two or more symbols have substantially thesame X-axis location (thereby exhibiting some level of persistent motionof their corresponding object), they are stacked vertically.Alternatively, a horizontal growth metric may be used. Alternatively oradditionally, the histogram could be implemented by a set of counterswherein each counter in the set corresponds to an X-axis location withinan amalgamated image. If a blob having a center of gravity correspondingto the X-axis location of a given counter is identified in anamalgamated image, the corresponding counter is incremented. Therefore,the larger the number of times a blob appears in a series of amalgamatedimages, the larger the value in the corresponding counter becomes.

To determine whether any symbol in the histogram has exhibitedsufficient persistent motion to be counted as a person in the audience,the blob discriminator 190 is further provided with a threshold counter198. The threshold counter 198 compares the number of times each centerof gravity is represented in the histogram to a predetermined threshold.This can be done, for example, by comparing the size of the symbol tothe predetermined threshold. If any symbol in the histogram has a sizegreater than the threshold, it is counted as a person. Thus, in theexample of FIGS. 1-4, the CURRENT COUNT variable is incremented one timefor every symbol having a size that exceeds the predetermined threshold.

In the people counter 20 of FIGS. 5-6, a histogram and, thus, a peoplecount, is not developed for every possible sequence of amalgamatedimages. Instead, a histogram is made only when there is sufficientmotion in the room being monitored to suggest that an audiencecomposition change may be occurring (e.g., someone walking into or outof a room appears as a large amount of motion compared to an audiencesitting in front of an information device). To determine when to developand analyze a histogram, the blob discriminator 190 is further providedwith an energy detector 200. For each difference image developed by themotion detector 180, the energy detector 200 computes an energy value.In the illustrated example, the energy value is computed by squaringeach array representing a difference image and summing the valuescorresponding to the elements in the squared array. If the summed valueexceeds a predetermined energy threshold, the difference image has acorresponding energy level that suggests an audience change may beoccurring. Therefore, whenever a difference image that exceeds theenergy threshold is detected by the energy detector 200, the energydetector 200 sets a motion marker in association with that differenceimage.

The people counts developed at the motion markers can be extrapolated tothe periods occurring between motion markers. This extrapolation ispossible because there is relatively little motion between the motionmarkers. Someone entering or leaving the audience room is associatedwith a significant amount of motion. Since motion markers are set whensuch a significant amount of motion occurs, no significant amount ofmotion occurs between motion markers, and it can, thus, be safelyassumed that no one has left or entered the room in the time betweenmotion markers. Therefore, it can be safely assumed that the audiencecomposition has not changed in the time between motion markers. By wayof an example, if at a first motion marker the people counter 20determines there are 2 people in the audience, and at the next motionmarker the people counter determines there are three people in the room,then, because no motion indicating a person has entered or exited theroom is detected prior to the second motion marker, the people count forthe entire period from the first motion marker to the second motionmarker is two people.

When sufficient data has been developed around a motion marker (e.g.,when enough amalgamated images prior to and after a motion marker havebeen analyzed for the corresponding histogram developed from thoseamalgamated images to have meaning, the threshold counter 198 isactivated. As explained above, the threshold counter 198 determineswhether any blob represented in the histogram has exhibited sufficientpersistence of motion to be counted as a person. Any such blob iscounted as a person and the person count so developed is output by thepeople counter 20.

To prevent noise and false motions from cluttering the histogram, theblob discriminator 190 is further provided with a false motion filter202. The false motion detector 202 of the illustrated example reviewsthe symbols recorded in the histogram as the histogram is beingdeveloped. If any symbol does not grow for a predetermined amount oftime (e.g., three minutes), the symbol is assumed to be noise or otherfalse motion and is eliminated from the histogram. In this way,erroneous entries due to noise, random movement, or erroneousconsolidation of two or more blobs into one blob are not allowed togrow.

An example software program for implementing the apparatus 20 of FIGS.5-6, is shown in FIGS. 7A-7C. In this example, the program is forexecution by a processor such as the processor 54 shown in the exampleof FIG. 3, and the program is embodied in software stored on a tangiblemedium such as a compact disk (CD), a floppy disk, a hard drive, adigital versatile disk (DVD), or a memory associated with the processor54. However, persons of ordinary skill in the art will readilyappreciate that the entire program or parts thereof could alternativelybe executed by a device other than the processor 54 and/or embodied infirmware or dedicated hardware in a well known manner. For example, anyor all of the motion detector 180, the shape outliner 182, the imageamalgamator 184, the blob discriminator 190, the non-human filter 188,the center locator 192, the center comparator 194, the energy detector200, the threshold counter 198 and/or the false motion filter 202 couldbe implemented by software, hardware, and/or firmware. Further, althoughthe example program is described with reference to the flowchartillustrated in FIGS. 7A-7C, persons of ordinary skill in the art willreadily appreciate that many other methods of implementing the examplepeople counter 20 may alternatively be used. For example, the order ofexecution of the blocks may be changed, and/or some of the blocksdescribed may be changed, eliminated, and/or combined.

The program of FIGS. 7A-7C may be used with the program of FIGS. 4A-4Dto implement the apparatus 10. If so implemented, the program of FIGS.7A-7C replaces blocks 122-128 of FIG. 4B. However, persons of ordinaryskill in the art will readily appreciate that the program of FIGS. 7A-7Ccould be implemented without the program of FIGS. 4A-4D or vice versa.For example, the program of FIGS. 4A-4D could use an entirely differentmethod of counting people in an image and/or the program of FIGS. 7A-7Ccould be used for applications other than audience measurement. In thefollowing, it is assumed that the program of FIGS. 7A-7C is used in theprogram of FIGS. 4A-4D. Therefore, in this example, control enters theprogram of FIG. 7A via block 118 or 120 of FIG. 4B.

Turning to FIG. 7A, the program begins when the image sensor 18 capturesan image of the audience in question (block 220). The digitizer 52 thendigitizes the captured image into an array of eight bit values asexplained above (block 222). If this is the first image captured by thesensor 18 (i.e., the program has just been started after a power-offtime), then two images are captured and digitized (blocks 220-222). Thedigitized image(s) are then saved in the memory 30 (block 224).

The motion detector 180 then computes the difference image between themost recently captured image and the immediately preceding image storedin memory (block 226). As discussed above, the difference image iscalculated by subtracting the elements of the most recently capturedimage array from the corresponding elements of the most recently storedimage array in accordance with the conventional rules of linear algebra.

Once the difference image is calculated (block 226), the energy detector200 calculates the energy value associated with the difference image(block 228). As explained above, this energy value is computed bysquaring the array of the difference image and then summing all of thevalues contained in the array generated by the squaring operation. Theenergy value is stored in memory 30 for later use as explained below.

Because many of the calculations performed by the people counter 20require data corresponding to images taken before and after a motionmarker, it is necessary to have a running sequence of pictures tooperate upon. Therefore, before creating any amalgamated images, thepeople counter 20 creates a buffer of captured images and differenceimages. Thus, at block 230, the people counter 20 determines whether thedesired buffer has been created. If not, control loops back to block 220via block 232. At block 232 a captured image counter i is incremented.Control continues to loop through blocks 220-232 until the desiredbuffer of captured images and difference images corresponding to thosecaptured images has been created (block 230).

Assuming the desired buffer is in place (block 230), control advances toblock 234. At block 234 a number of counters are initialized. Forexample, an amalgamation counter A is set to equal the image counter iless the buffer size. A histogram loop counter B is set to equal theamalgamation counter less a delay value sufficient to ensure all neededamalgamation image arrays have been computed prior to initiatingpopulation of a histogram. A range counter K is set to equal theamalgamation counter A-Z, a variable setting the earliest differenceimage to be used in creating an amalgamated image corresponding to timeA. A range counter M is set to equal the histogram loop counter B-P, avariable setting the earliest amalgamated image to be used in creating ahistogram corresponding to a motion marker occurring at time B. Athreshold T is set equal to the amalgamation counter A+E, a variablesetting the latest difference image to be used in creating anamalgamated image corresponding to time A. A second threshold U is setto equal the histogram loop counter B+F, a variable setting the latestamalgamated image to be used in creating a histogram corresponding to amotion marker occurring at time B. Additionally, the amalgamation arrayS_(A) for time A is cleared to an empty set. Persons of ordinary skillin the art will appreciate that the variables Z and E may optionally beidentical. Similarly, the variables P and F may optionally be identical.

Once the variables are initialized as explained above (block 234), theimage amalgamator 184 sums the amalgamation array SA with the differenceimage array associated with time K on an element by element basis (block236). The counter K is then incremented (block 238). If the counter Khas not surpassed the threshold T (block 240), control returns to block236 where the image amalgamator 184 adds the next difference image arrayto the amalgamated image array. Control continues to loop through blocks236-240 until the counter K equals or exceeds the threshold T (block240).

When the compilation of the amalgamated image array is completed (block240), the image amalgamator 184 converts the amalgamated image array SAinto a binary image (block 242). Converting the amalgamated image arrayto a binary image can be accomplished by, for example, dividing eachelement in the amalgamated image array by the number of differenceimages used to form the amalgamated image array (e.g., by (Z+E)).

The energy detector 200 then determines whether the energy valueassociated with time B is greater than an energy threshold X (i.e.,whether a motion marker is set at time B) (block 244). The energythreshold X is a value that indicates the amount of movement energy thatis required in a difference image to suggest that an audiencecomposition change is occurring. If a motion marker is set at time B,then control advances to block 250. Otherwise, the people counterroutine determines whether it has been executing for too long of a time(block 246). If so, the people counter routine terminates and controladvances to block 134 of FIG. 4B. As with many blocks of FIGS. 7A-7C,block 246 is not required in all applications. It is included in theillustrated example wherein the people counter routine is inserted inthe program of FIGS. 4A-4D to enable the program to periodically checkfor source changes (block 118). Were blocks 246 not employed in thiscontext, it would be possible to miss several source changes occurringwhile the audience composition remains constant as control wouldotherwise continue to loop within the people counter routine until amotion marker were reached.

Assuming it is not time to exit the people counter routine to check forsource changes or a turn-off event (block 246), control advances toblock 248. At block 248 the captured image counter i is incremented.Control then returns to block 220 (FIG. 7A) where another image iscaptured. Control continues to loop through blocks 220-248 until amotion marker is reached (block 244), or a time to check for a sourcechange or turn-off event is reached (block 246).

Assuming for purposes of discussion that a motion marker is located attime B (block 244), control enters a loop wherein a histogramcorresponding to the time period beginning at time M (i.e., time (B−P))and ending at time U (i.e., time (B+F)) is populated. In particular, atblock 250, the shape outliner 182 executes the convex hull process onthe points appearing in the amalgamated image array SM corresponding totime M. As explained above, if any points are presenting the amalgamatedimage array SM, the execution of the convex hull process draws one ormore blob(s) in the amalgamated image array SM.

Once the blob(s) (if any) are drawn, the non-human filter 188 performsone or more logic test(s) on the blob(s) to attempt to eliminatenon-human blob(s) from the amalgamated image array SM (block 252). Asexplained above, many different logic tests may be used for this purposeincluding, by way of examples, not limitations, a location test and/or asize test.

Once the non-human filter 188 has completed execution, the centerlocator 192 calculates the center of gravity of each remaining blob (ifany) in the amalgamated image array SM (block 254). As explained above,this calculation may be performed by averaging the X-axis values foreach point in the blob in question.

Irrespective of how the center(s) of the blob(s) are identified, oncethe centers are calculated, the center comparator 192 attempts to recordthe blob(s) in the histogram. In particular, the center comparator 192determines if the center of a first one of the blob(s) (if any) in theamalgamated image SM is located within a predetermined distance Y of acenter of an object already recorded in the histogram (block 256). Thepredetermined distance is preferably selected to correspond to theexpected size of a person along the x-axis of an image (e.g., 40pixels). As explained above, this test is performed to ensure thatslight differences in the centers of blobs do not cause the same blob tobe identified as two different blobs in different amalgamated images. Ifthe center of the blob under consideration is within Y distance of acenter already existing in the histogram (block 256), a symbolrepresentative of the blob under consideration is added to the symbolrepresenting the already existing center in the histogram (block 258,FIG. 7C). If the center of the blob under consideration is not within Ydistance of a center already existing in the histogram (block 256), asymbol representative of the blob under consideration is added to thehistogram as a new center representing a new blob (block 260, FIG. 7C).

Irrespective of whether control passes through block 258 or 260, whencontrol reaches block 262, the center comparator 194 determines if thereare more blobs to analyze within the amalgamated image SM underexamination. If so, control returns to block 256 (FIG. 7B). Controlcontinues to loop through blocks 256-262 until every blob appearing inthe amalgamated image SM has been represented in the histogram. Controlthen advances to block 264.

At block 264, the range counter M is incremented. The blob discriminator196 then determines whether the loop counter M is equal to or greaterthan the threshold U (block 266). If not, then all of the amalgamatedimages to be represented in the histogram have not yet been analyzed,and control advances to block 268. Otherwise, the histogram is completeand control advances to block 272.

Assuming for purposes of discussion that the histogram is not yet fullypopulated (block 266), the false motion filter 202 examines thehistogram to determine if any symbols in the histogram have failed togrow within a predetermined time period (e.g., 3 minutes)(block 268). Ifany such inactive symbols exist (block 268), the false motion filter 202assumes these inactive symbols are not representative of people andremoves them from the histogram (block 270). Control then returns toblock 250 (FIG. 7B) wherein the shape outliner 182 draws blob(s) aroundany points present in the next amalgamated image SM. If no inactivesymbols exist in the histogram (block 268), control advances directlyfrom block 268 (FIG. 7C) to block 250 (FIG. 7B).

Control continues to loop through blocks 250-270 until the loop counterM becomes equal to or greater than the threshold U (block 266). Thehistogram is then complete and ready for analysis. Accordingly, thehistogram is latched and stored.

The threshold counter 198 then begins analyzing each symbolrepresentative of a blob center appearing in the histogram (block 272).If a symbol being examined exceeds a predetermined threshold (block272), the threshold counter 198 identifies the symbol as representativeof a person. Accordingly, the CURRENT COUNT variable is incremented(block 274). If the symbol being examined does not exceed thepredetermined threshold (block 272), the threshold counter 198 concludesthat the symbol represents something other than a person and the CURRENTCOUNT variable is, therefore, not incremented (block 272). The thresholdcounter 198 then determines if every symbol in the histogram has beenanalyzed (block 276). If not, control returns to block 272. Controlcontinues to loop through blocks 272-276 until every symbol in thehistogram has been identified as human or non-human and the humansymbols have been counted (block 276). Once this process is completed(block 276), the histogram is cleared for the next round of analysis(block 278). The people counter routine then terminates. In the exampleof FIGS. 4A-4D, control then advances to block 134 of FIG. 4B.

To provide further illustration of the operation of the people counter20 discussed in connection with FIGS. 5-7, an example histogram whichcould be generated by such an apparatus is shown in FIGS. 8A-8G. In theexample of FIG. 8A, two blobs are present in the first amalgamated imageexamined by the blob discriminator 190. The centers of these blobs arecalculated by the center locator 192 as being separated by more than thedistance Y (e.g., 40 pixels). Accordingly, the two blobs are representedby two separate symbols A and B. Each of the symbols is located at theX-axis location of the blob it represents.

As shown in FIG. 8B, the next amalgamated image examined by the blobdiscriminator 190 contains 4 blobs. A first blob has a center identicalto the center of symbol A. Therefore, a symbol representing the firstblob is stacked on top of the symbol A such that symbol A “grows.”Similarly, a second blob having a center identical to the center ofsymbol B is present in the second amalgamated image. Accordingly, symbolB also grows by virtue of the addition of another symbol to its height.The remaining two blobs have calculated centers that are separated by adistance greater than Y from both the center represented by symbol A andthe center represented by symbol B. Accordingly, two new symbols C and Dare added to the histogram at X-axis locations corresponding to thecenters of the blobs they represent.

The third amalgamated image contains only one blob. As shown in FIG. 8C,that blob has a center located less than the distance Y from the centerrepresented by symbol A (see symbol E). Accordingly, the centercomparator 194 assumes that symbol E and symbol A represent the sameobject, and as shown in FIG. 8D, symbol E is merged with symbol A suchthat symbol A again grows.

FIG. 8E represents the state of the histogram after several additionalamalgamated images have been analyzed. As shown in FIG. 8E, the symbolsA, B and C have all grown (although at different rates) since the timereflected in FIG. 8D. Symbol D, however, has not grown in that timeperiod. Accordingly, as shown in FIG. 8F, the false motion filter 202assumes the inactive symbol D corresponds to noise or some othernon-human source, and the symbol D is, therefore, eliminated from thehistogram.

As also shown in FIG. 8F, the amalgamated image being added at this timehas two blobs. One blob has the same center as symbol A and is, thus,merged with that symbol (compare FIG. 8E). The other blob (see symbol F)has a slightly different center than symbol B. However, the center ofthe second blob is less than the distance Y from the center representedby symbol B. Accordingly, as shown in FIG. 8G, the symbol F is mergedwith the symbol B.

In the final state of the histogram reflected in FIG. 8G, symbols A andB have again grown and a new symbol G corresponding to a third blobappearing in the last amalgamated image has been added. In the finallatched state shown in FIG. 8G, the symbols A and B are seen to havegrown beyond the threshold frequency. Therefore, when the thresholdcounter 198 examines the histogram, it identifies symbols A and B ascorresponding to persons, but symbols C and G are considered to berepresentative of non-humans. Accordingly, the threshold counter 198counts two persons in the example of FIG. 8G.

Although certain example methods and apparatus constructed in accordancewith the teachings of the invention have been described herein, thescope of coverage of this patent is not limited thereto. On thecontrary, this patent covers all embodiments of the teachings of theinvention fairly falling within the scope of the appended claims eitherliterally or under the doctrine of equivalents.

1. A method of detecting a composition of an audience of an informationpresenting device comprising: capturing at least one image of theaudience; determining a number of people within the at least one image;prompting the audience to identify its members if a change in the numberof people is detected based on the number of people determined to bewithin the at least one image; and if a number of members identified bythe audience is different from the determined number of people after apredetermined number of prompts of the audience, adjusting a value toavoid excessive prompting of the audience.
 2. A method as defined inclaim 1, wherein adjusting the value comprises increasing a previousaudience count by a difference between the number of members identifiedby the audience and the number of people determined from the at leastone image.
 3. A method as defined in claim 2, further comprisingrecording the difference between the number of members identified by theaudience and the number of people determined from the at least one imageas a number of unidentified audience members.
 4. A method as defined inclaim 1 further comprising periodically exporting recorded data to adevice to identify audiences and programs being consumed by theaudiences.
 5. An apparatus to detect a composition of an audience of aninformation presenting device comprising: a camera to capture at leastone image of the audience; a processor; a memory storing computerreadable instructions which, when executed, cause the processor to:determine a number of people within the at least one image; develop aprompt signal requesting the audience to identify its members if achange in the number of people is visually detected; and an outputdevice responsive to the prompt signal to output an indicationrequesting the audience to identify its members; and if a number ofmembers identified by the audience is different from the determinednumber of people after a number of prompts of the audience, the computerreadable instructions cause the processor to adjust a value to avoidexcessive prompting of the audience.
 6. An apparatus as defined in claim5 wherein the processor adjusts the value by increasing a previousaudience count by a difference between the number of members identifiedby the audience and the number of people determined from the at leastone image.
 7. An apparatus as defined in claim 6 wherein the computerreadable instructions cause the processor to record the differencebetween the number of members identified by the audience and the numberof people determined from the at least one image as a number ofunidentified audience members.
 8. A computer readable medium storingmachine readable instructions which, when executed, cause at least onemachine to: capture at least one image of an audience consuming aprogram; determine a number of people within the at least one image;output a prompt signal requesting the audience to identify its membersif a change in the number of people is detected from the at least oneimage; and if a number of members identified by the audience isdifferent from the determined number of people after a number of promptsof the audience, the computer readable instructions cause the at leastone machine to adjust a value to avoid excessive prompting of theaudience.
 9. A computer readable medium as defined in claim 8 whereinthe at least one machine adjusts the value by increasing a previousaudience count by a difference between the number of members identifiedby the audience and the number of people determined from the at leastone image.
 10. A computer readable medium as defined in claim 9 whereinthe machine readable instructions cause the at least one machine torecord the difference between the number of members identified by theaudience and the number of people determined from the at least one imageas a number of unidentified audience members.
 11. An apparatus to detecta composition of an audience of an information presenting devicecomprising: an image sensor to capture at least one image of theaudience; a people counter to determine a number of people in the atleast one image; a change detector to compare the number of people inthe at least one image to a value representative of a previous number ofpeople in the audience; a prompter to request the audience to identifyits members if the change detector identifies a difference between thenumber of people in the at least one image and the value representativeof the previous number of people in the audience; and an input device toreceive data from the audience.
 12. An apparatus as defined in claim 11further comprising a compliance detector to determine if a member of theaudience is not being identified in response to the prompt.
 13. Anapparatus as defined in claim 11 wherein the people counter comprises: amotion detector to compare at least two images to detect motion; animage amalgamator to develop an amalgamated image from the at least twoimages; a shape outliner to draw at least one shape within theamalgamated image; and a blob discriminator to determine if the at leastone shape represents a person.
 14. An apparatus as defined in claim 13further comprising a non-human filter to eliminate a non-human shapefrom the at least one shape.
 15. An apparatus as defined in claim 14wherein the non-human filter eliminates the non-human shape based on atleast one of a location of the non-human shape and a size of thenon-human shape.
 16. An apparatus as defined in claim 13 wherein theblob discriminator comprises: a center locator to identify a center ofthe at least one shape; a center comparator to add a symbolrepresentative of the center of the at least one shape to a histogram;and a threshold counter to count symbols in the histogram exceeding apredetermined threshold.
 17. An apparatus as defined in claim 16 whereinif the center of the at least one shape substantially corresponds to anexisting center in the histogram, the center comparator adds the symbolrepresentative of the center of the at least one shape to a symbolrepresenting the existing center in the histogram.
 18. An apparatus asdefined in claim 16 further comprising an energy detector to compare avalue indicative of motion occurring between the two images to an energythreshold, and to cause the threshold counter to count the symbols inthe histogram exceeding the predetermined threshold if the value exceedsthe energy threshold.
 19. An apparatus as defined in claim 16 furthercomprising a false motion detector to eliminate a non-growing symbolfrom the histogram.
 20. An apparatus as defined in claim 11 wherein, ifa number of members identified by the audience is different from thenumber of people determined by the change detector after a predeterminednumber of prompts of the audience, a compliance detector adjusts thevalue representative of the previous number of people in the audience toavoid excessive prompting of the audience.
 21. An apparatus as definedin claim 20 wherein the compliance detector adjusts the value byincreasing the value representative of the previous number of people inthe audience by a difference between the number of members identified bythe audience and the number of people determined from the image by thepeople counter.
 22. An apparatus as defined in claim 21 wherein thecompliance detector records the difference between the number of membersidentified by the audience and the number of people determined from theat least one image as a number of unidentified audience member.
 23. Anapparatus as defined in claim 11 further comprising a content collectorto identify the program being consumed by the audience.
 24. An apparatusas defined in claim 11 further comprising an output device to exportrecorded data to a device to identify audiences and programs beingconsumed by the audiences.
 25. An apparatus as defined in claim 23wherein the content collector further comprises a program detector toidentify a source of the program being consumed by the audience.
 26. Anapparatus as defined in claim 25 further comprising a time stamper toidentify a consumption time, and a memory to record the source and theconsumption time.
 27. An apparatus as defined in claim 25 wherein theprogram detector identifies the source of the program by identifying atuned channel.